Deciding if you want to make egg-based pasta or water-based pasta depends on the tools that you have on hand and the shapes you like. Here is my synopsis on the differences you will find between the two doughs:
Opt for Egg-Pasta Dough when you're cooking for more people, it's a lot easier to make 100 noodles using a machine vs. the hand shaping you'll typically find with water-semola dough. You'll need a rolling pin or a pasta machine.
Opt for Semola-Pasta Dough if you love working with your hands and have no tools in sight. An extruder would be ideal, but my guess is that if you're coming to my site for pasta tips you probably don't have one of those.
Opt for Egg-Pasta Dough when you're cooking for more people, it's a lot easier to make 100 noodles using a machine vs. the hand shaping you'll typically find with water-semola dough.
Best case scenario for Egg-Pasta would be a Pasta Machine. Don’t have that? A rolling pin works too!
Extras: Digital scale, bench scraper, ziploc, wide-bowl or food processor
Ribbon-Pasta: Pappardelle, Tagliatelle, Lasagna, Tagliolini
Filled-Pasta: Ravioli, Tortellini, Caramelle, Fagottini, Cannelloni, Agnolotti, Cappelletti, Garganelli, Farfalle, Gigli
Serves 4 people
275 g Tipo '00' Flour
75 g Semola Flour
185 g Liquid (~ 3 eggs + a splash of water)
Serves 4 people
2 cups Tipo '00' Flour
2/3 cup Semola Flour
3 eggs
2 tbs water
Try to avoid making making pasta using cup measurements if you can! It's much harder to determine the proper hydration ratio.
Opt for Semola-Pasta Dough if you love shorter pasta and working with your hands.
Best case scenario for semola-dough would be an extruder. But those are expensive and you can just use your hands. Be prepared for this to take longer than rolling out noodles.
Extras: Butter knife, digital scale, bench scraper, garganelli board, ziploc, wide-bowl or food processor
Pici, Orecchiette, Gnocchetti Sardi, Trofie, Capunti, Busiate, Cavatelli
Serves 4 people
300 g Semola Flour
185 g Hot Water
Serves 4 people
2 + 2/3 cup Semola Flour
3/4 cup water
Try to avoid making making pasta using cup measurements if you can! It's much harder to determine the proper hydration ratio.
Check out my shape gallery for ideas.